MODULE 4
Understanding Alternative Investment Assets in Detail
  • Duration: 53 mins

Understanding Alternative Investment Assets in Detail

Performance Evaluation and Benchmarks

Evaluating and comparing the performance of different alternative investment options can be tricky for investors in India today. The universe of alternatives has expanded vastly beyond the traditional choices of gold and real estate. Asset classes like private equity, hedge funds, commodities, art and collectables are gaining more attention.

But how can investors analyse expected returns vis-à-vis risks across such varied assets? In this chapter, we will explore the concept of performance evaluation and benchmarks.

What is Performance Evaluation?

Performance evaluation involves measuring and comparing returns generated by different investment opportunities after accounting for the risks taken. This enables choosing assets that provide the best returns per unit of risk assumed.

For example, private equity, which is money invested in private companies, often makes more money than investing in a big list of companies called the S&P 500.

By looking at risk-adjusted returns, investors can identify investment opportunities that provide superior returns per unit of risk taken. Essentially, performance evaluation helps select investments where the probability of gains adequately compensates the risks. It enables the construction of an optimal portfolio that maximises returns for the given risk appetite.

The Art of Performance Evaluation in Private Markets

Performance evaluation in private markets is more art than science. It involves assessing not just the financial returns but also the strategic growth and market position of investments, which often include private equity, real estate, and venture capital.

  • Complex Metrics: Unlike public markets, where performance is often gauged by stock prices and market capitalisation, private market investments require a deeper dive. Here, metrics like Internal Rate of Return (IRR), Distribution to Paid-in Capital (DPI), cash-on-cash returns, and multiples on invested capital come into play.
  • Long-Term Horizon: Private market investments typically have a longer-term horizon. This means performance evaluation must consider how investments evolve and mature over time, often spanning several years.
  • Wider Range of Strategies: There is considerable diversity in alternative asset strategies, ranging from passive index tracking funds to active hedge funds with dynamic trading strategies across asset classes. Their risk-return profiles can vary significantly.
  • Lack of Regulation: Alternatives are relatively less regulated than traditional assets. There are fewer standardised disclosure requirements. Performance evaluation provides transparency.
  • High Costs: Management and performance fees for alternatives can be steep, especially in active strategies. Evaluating if higher costs result in superior risk-adjusted returns is essential.

Methodologies for Performance Evaluation

  1. Multiple of Invested Capital

    This metric is far-sighted. It does not care about smaller deviations here and there. It only cares about where you end at the close of the day.

    It’s like measuring the total treasure you’ve unearthed compared to your initial digging effort, or in financial terms, the total value returned from an investment relative to the amount initially invested.

    MOIC is calculated by dividing the current value of an investment (including any distributions received) by the original amount invested.

    Let’s imagine two treasure hunts.

    In the first, you find small treasures ($10,000) yearly for 10 years. In the second, you find a huge chest ($200,000) at the end of 10 years. MOIC points to the big chest as the greater treasure, not minding that it took a decade to find.

    MOIC is quite an absolute measure. It’s a simple but effective way to gauge how much value an investment has generated in absolute terms, without factoring in the time taken to achieve those returns.

  2. Internal Rate of Return

    IRR measures the annualised rate of return generated by an investment over its lifetime. It equals the discount rate at which the net present value of costs equals the net present value of returns.

    For example, imagine two different investments as follows.

    Investors A and B both invest $100,000 each in a startup of their choice.

    Within a year, Investor A exits with $120,000. The MOIC is 1.2x ($120,000 / $100,000) in this case, but the IRR is high because the return was achieved quickly.

    Investor B, on the other hand, stays invested over five years and then exits with $200,000. The MOIC is 2x ($200,000 / $100,000) in this case. The IRR is lower because the return took longer, despite the higher overall return.

    In other words — IRR prioritises faster returns as opposed to a gradual build-up. It also does not take into account the other qualities or even the conditions of the market.

  3. Public Market Equivalent (PME)

    PME analysis is used to calculate the alpha of private equity funds relative to the public markets. This measure is based on a completely different premise. It asks the question: “How would this private equity investment have fared if the same amount of money had been invested in the public market instead?”

    Let’s consider an investment made in a private equity fund and a parallel hypothetical investment in a public market index.

    Imagine you have two investment options. Each requires the same cash investments at the same times, but one is in a private equity fund and the other in a public market index.

    The private equity investment involves specific cash inflows (investments) and outflows (returns) over the fund’s lifetime. The timing and amounts of these cash flows are key. For the public market equivalent investment, we replicate the exact timing and amounts of the cash flows from the private equity investment into a public market index.

    PME analysis compares the final value of the private equity investment with the final value of the hypothetical public market investment. It provides a direct, date-and-cash-flow-matched analysis of returns between the two investment scenarios.

    It is important to note that PME is not about assessing the risks, or the investment journey of the private equity fund or the public market index. Rather, it offers a method to directly compare the returns of the two, assuming identical cash flow patterns. The focus is on the performance outcomes, not on the risk profiles or investment strategies of the respective investments.

What are Benchmarks?

In investing, a benchmark is a standard point of reference used to evaluate the performance of a portfolio. Benchmarking allows investors to compare the returns generated by their portfolio to a suitable market index or composite. This helps assess how well the portfolio is doing relative to the overall market.

In 2023, many index or large-cap funds that just follow the market couldn’t do better than the benchmarks they were compared to. This means the funds didn’t earn more money than the average market performance.

A benchmark should represent the investment universe and risk-return profile of the portfolio it is being compared against. For example, a large-cap equity fund would be benchmarked to a major index like the S&P 500 that covers the large-cap space.

The Role of Benchmarks in Alternative Investments

Benchmarks are really important in alternative investments because they help investors see how well their money is doing compared to other options. They are like a scorecard.

For example, in the first half of 2023, a huge number of equity funds in France, Italy, and Spain didn’t perform as well as their benchmarks. Specifically, 94% in France, 96% in Italy, and 99% in Spain fell short. This shows that most funds in these countries couldn’t beat the average market performance.

In the context of private equity and venture capital funds, vintage year benchmarks are particularly significant. These are the performance metrics of investment funds categorised by the year they started making investments. This is crucial because funds of the same vintage year are exposed to similar market conditions and economic cycles. Comparing funds based on their vintage year therefore offers a more meaningful performance assessment, as opposed to general market benchmarks that might not reflect the unique nature of these investments.

Vintage year benchmarks serve several roles:

  • Performance Comparison: By grouping funds based on their inception year, investors can compare funds against a more relevant and fair benchmark. For instance, a PE fund started in 2015 would be benchmarked against other funds that began in the same year.
  • Market Context: These benchmarks help in understanding how specific market conditions in a given year affected investment strategies and returns. They account for economic cycles, making them crucial for evaluating long-term investments like PE and VC.
  • Strategic Insights: Investors use vintage year benchmarks to gain insights into the effectiveness of different investment strategies during specific periods. This assists in making informed decisions for future investments.
  • Portfolio Construction: For investors building a diversified portfolio, understanding how funds of different vintage years have performed helps in selecting a mix of investments that can balance risk and return over time.

Benchmarks are indispensable yardsticks that bring transparency and perspective to performance evaluation for investment portfolios.

Comparing Performance Across Asset Classes

Let’s take a look at how some of these classes compare:

Asset Class What It Is Risks Typical Returns Good For
Stocks Owning a part of a company. Can lose value fast. Can be high, but varies. Long-term growth.
Bonds Lending money, usually to a government or company. Low, unless the borrower can’t pay back. Usually lower than stocks, but steadier. Stable income.
Real Estate Owning property, like houses or buildings. Depends on the property market. Can be good, especially if property prices go up. Long-term investment and rental income.
Commodities Physical goods like oil, gold, or wheat.Physical goods like oil, gold, or wheat. Prices can change a lot due to market conditions. Can be very good, but unpredictable. Diversification and protection against inflation.
Art & Collectibles Things like paintings or rare items. Value can change based on demand and rarity. Hard to predict, can be very high Long-term investment and personal enjoyment.
Key aspects:
  • Private equity has delivered the highest returns historically but also tends to be highly illiquid and risky. Hedge funds provide moderate returns with lower volatility and drawdowns.
  • Commodities and art/collectables provide high returns during bull markets but suffer from deep drawdowns in bear phases. They rank lower on risk-adjusted return metrics.
  • Real estate and infrastructure offer steady cash flows but are relatively illiquid investments with moderate returns for the locked-in periods.

TERMS OF USE

Thank you for your interest in our Website at https://unlistedintel.com/. Your use of this Website, including the content, materials and information available on or through this Website (together, the “Materials”), is governed by these Terms of Use (these “Terms”). By using this Website, you acknowledge that you have read and agree to these Terms.

NO OFFER, SOLICITATION OR ADVICE

Our site is provided for informational purposes only. It does not constitute to constitute (i) an offer, or solicitation of an offer, to

purchase or sell any security, other assets, or service, (ii) investment, legal, business, or tax advice, or an offer to provide such advice or (iii) a basis for making any investment decision.

The Materials are provided for informational purposes and have been prepared by Oister Global for informational purposes to acquaint existing and prospective underlying funds, entrepreneurs, and other company founders with Oister Global's recent and historical investment activities.

Please note that any investments or portfolio companies referenced in the Materials are illustrative and do not reflect the performance of any Oister Global fund as a whole. There is no obligation for Oister Global to update or alter any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events, or otherwise.

PURPOSE LIMITATION AND ACCESS TO YOUR PERSONAL DATA:

We will only collect your personal data in a fair, lawful, and transparent manner. We will keep your personal data accurate and up to date. We will process your personal data in line with your legal rights. We use your name and contact details, such as email, postal address, and contact number to continue communications with you. We may also use your contact information to invite you to events we are hosting or to keep you updated with our news.

USE OF COOKIES OR SIMILAR DEVICES

We use cookies on our website. This helps us to provide you with a better experience when you browse our website and also allows us to make improvements to our site. You may be able to change the preferences on your browser or device to prevent or limit your device’s acceptance of cookies, but this may prevent you from taking advantage of some of our features.

MATERIAL

The material displayed on our site is provided “as is”, without any guarantees, conditions, or warranties as to its accuracy, completeness, or reliability. You should be aware that a significant portion of the Materials includes or consists of information that has been provided by third parties and has not been validated or verified by us. In connection with our investment activities, we often become subject to a variety of confidentiality obligations to funds, investors, portfolio companies, and other third parties. Any statements we make may be affected by those confidentiality obligations, with the result that we may be prohibited from making full disclosures.

MISCELLANEOUS

This Website is operated and controlled by Oister Global in India. We may change the content on our site at any time. If the need arises, we may suspend access to our site, or close it indefinitely. We are under no obligation to update any material on our site.

CONTACT INFORMATION

Any questions, concerns or complaints regarding these Terms should be sent to info@oisterglobal.com